Problem 11-16 Source:
Problem 41 - List of
Electrical Circuits I Exercises - School of Engineering - UFRGS - 2011 - Prof.
Dr. Valner Brusamarello
In the circuit shown in Figure 11-16.1, when the switch “S” is in
position 1, the voltmeter
indicates a value of -16 volts.
a) Determine the value of “E”.
Determine the voltmeter reading:
b) When the “S” switch is in “position 2”.
c) When switch “S” is in “position 3”.
Figure 11-16.1
Attention: There is a typo in the answer in the exercise list. The value measured by the voltmeter,
in position 1, was one of the data points in the problem. For position 2, the “MINUS” sign was missing.
All other answers are correct.
Solution of the Problem 11-16 -
Method of Transforming Sources
Item a
In the circuit shown in Figure 11-16.2, the red line and green line emphasize
the points that are interconnected.
The resistor with a value of
5 Ω, which was in series
with the current source 6 i, was eliminated because
it does not interfere with the results.
Note that when switch S is in position 1, the
60 Ω resistors (through which current i flows)
and the 12 Ω resistors
are in parallel. Therefore, they are under the same potential difference.
So,
if i passes through 60 Ω, then 5 i will pass through the
12 Ω resistor. See the modified circuit below.
Figure 11-16.2
With this information in hand, and bearing in mind that the red line connects
all the elements linked to it,
the circuit was redesigned to provide a more objective view.
Don't forget that the S switch is in position 1.
Try to understand the changes that have been made
and conclude that the two circuits are absolutely identical,
although with
different topologies, as shown in Figure 11-16.3. Look carefully at
where the green and red lines are now.
Figure 11-16.3
By making some changes to the sources, it is possible to simplify the circuit further.
With the current source 6 i and the resistor of 5 Ω, is calculated the equivalent Thévenin.
The 5 Ω resistor must be added to the 55 Ω resistor
(as they will be in series) and results in a
value of 60 Ω. This resistor will be in
series with a voltage source of 30 i.
And making a Norton circuit results in a current source of 0.5 i
in parallel with the 60 Ω resistor.
It is easy to see that a current i will also flow through this resistor, since it is in parallel with the
other
60 Ω resistor (right side of the circuit). See Figure 11-16.4 for the
transformations performed.
Figure 11-16.4
The circuit highlighted in yellow in the figure above can be simplified. Initially, V₁ = +16 volts.
Note that
V1 has the opposite polarity to V (voltage measured by the voltmeter). Therefore, the
V1/4 source
in the circuit shown in Figure 16-03 can be replaced by a 4 V voltage source,
as shown in Figure 16-04.
The Norton of the two voltage sources with their respective
resistors in series must be calculated.
Calculate the equivalent resistor value of the parallel circuit between
the 5 Ω and 30 Ω
resistors and add the 2 Ω resistor (since they are in series).
Thus, it is possible to
simplify the entire circuit highlighted in yellow by a voltage source in series with
a resistor.
See Figure 11-16.5 for the simplified circuit. Note that no current passes through the voltmeter ,
as it is considered an ideal instrument and therefore has infinite resistance.
Figure 11-16.5
Note that the current of 7.5 i flowing down the circuit highlighted in yellow
is the sum of all
the currents flowing up the circuit, that is, 5 i + i + i + 0.5 i = 7.5 i.
We know that V = -16 volts, so it is easy to calculate the
value of the current i, because:
i = V / 60 = - 16 / 60 = - 4 / 15 A
By creating a circuit that includes the voltage source, resistor, and V1,
we find the equation that will allow us to calculate the value of E, that is:
- 16 + (220/35) (7.5) (- 4/15) - E/7 + 24/7 = 0
Performing the calculation, we find the value of E, or:
E = - 176 Volts
Item b
To answer item b, consider the same modifications made
in item a, but
replacing the 12 Ω resistor with a 21 Volt voltage source
in series with a
24 Ω resistor, which is the case with switch “S” in position 2.
It is very important to understand that when
switch “S” is in position 2,
the reading of the voltmeter is unknown.
Figure 11-16.6
Making the Norton equivalent circuit from the 21 volts source with the 24 Ω resistor, we get the circuit
shown in Figura 11-16.6. Note that we have a current source
of 7/8 ampère (pointing downwards) in parallel
with a
resistor of 24 Ω. From the data in the problem, we know that a current equal to i
flows through the resistor
of 60 Ω
Thus, looking
closely at the circuit, we can conclude that V1 = - 60 i. So, it is possible
to
replace the source V1 / 4 with 15 i, not forgetting that the polarity of the
source must be reversed, since V1 = - 60 i.
It can also be concluded that in the
resistor of 24 Ω that is in parallel with the resistor of 60 Ω,
2.5 i passes.
Therefore, substituting these values in the circuit,
we obtain the circuit shown in Figure 11-16.7.
Figure 11-16.7
Finally, work on the circuit highlighted in yellow and simplify it. See
Figure 11-16.8 for the redesigned
circuit. Note that the current flowing down the
220/35 resistor is the result of the equation node a
(i + 0.5 i + i + 2.5 i - 7/8 = 5 i - 7/8),
as shown in the figure below.
Figure 11-16.8
By making the mesh of V1 with the branch containing the voltage source
that depends on i,
the value of i can be calculated, since V1
also depends on i.
Thus, the following equation is found:
Therefore, solving the equation, we arrive at the value of i, or:
i = - 0.25 A
Now, remembering that V1 = - 60 i = 15 Volts and not
forgetting that the voltage
measured by the voltmeter has the opposite polarity to
V1 (see note after the problem statement),
we conclude that V
(value measured by the voltmeter) has the value of:
V = - 15 volts
Item c
For item c, the same considerations apply as for item b, noting that
the voltage source
in series with the resistor has been replaced by a current source of
8.5 A in parallel with a
resistor of 4 Ω. The following relationship also applies
V1 = - 60 i .
Figure 11-16.9 shows the modified circuit.
Figure 11-16.9
The process is the same as that used in item a. By connecting
V1 to the
branch containing the voltage source
that depends on i, the value of i can be calculated,
since V1 = - 60 i .
Thus, the following equation is found:
60 i + 110 i + 374/7 + 176/7 - (90/7) i = 0
In the equation above, the term that appears as 110 i + 374/7 is the result of the
product
220/35 x (17.5 i + 8.5). Therefore, solving the equation gives the value of i, or:
i = - 0.5 A
So, remembering that V1 = - 60 i = 30 Volts and not forgetting that the voltage V,
measured by the voltmeter, has the opposite polarity to
V1, we conclude that V
(value measured by the voltmeter) is equal to: